6 Stone Jars Marriage Preparation Resources for Catholic Singles

Guidance on Catholic dating, courtship, relationships and marriage in the name of
fostering successful marriages that are permanent, faithful and fruitful.

Ask Anthony your questions about Catholic Dating and Marriage Retreats and Trips for Single Catholics Road to Cana Series Video Clips Subscribe options for 6 Stone Jars: Is he interested or just being polite? Follow 6stonejars on Twitter
 

Is he interested or just being polite?

Dear Anthony,

I’m a member of Ave Maria Singles. I initiated contact with another member and he replied that the long distance between us was a problem for him, but to feel free to correspond. I replied that I try not to make distance an issue and encouraged him to do the same. I don’t know if he is really interested or just being polite. What do you think? I’m not looking for a pen pal.


No need to overcomplicate this. If a man is interested, he is going to pursue. This man is not going to pursue you. His leaving it open for you to still contact him means that he is not trying to cut you off if you still just want to write. But he is not interested. My advice is to move on and not contact him again. You said your piece, and were right to do so (saying you have a different opinion on the matter of long distance). But again, men don't let opportunities go. If he was interested in you, he would not make distance an issue and he would continue writing to you.

Yours in Christ,
Anthony

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
Patricia's Gravatar correction: Real men don't let opportunities (as in good women) go!
# Posted By Patricia | 8/8/09 8:33 PM
Kelly's Gravatar Hi...Sounds like someone I know..I had the same thing happen. After corresponding about 5 times with the man I contacted, I told him up front what I was looking for. I told him that if there wasn't any hope of a relationship in the future that I would have to move on. He agreed that we should move on. I notice that he is on the site ALOT! Is he doing this with other women too? I had to be strong as much as I was interested. I don't have time to waste and neither do you.
# Posted By Kelly | 8/9/09 2:06 PM
Mark Pennington's Gravatar Anthony, Yes, the quick answer is that men do not let opportunities they are interested in pass them by. However the long answer is that ... it depends upon the mood they're in. Obviously I'm only speaking for myself, as a man, and I'm generalizing a bit on behalf of all the "guy talk" I've had with other men. For example, I think younger men will let more opportunities go than older men. Depending upon many other variables, I'd suggest the woman write him a couple of times without over-investing. Give him a few weeks to get over the recent car-break-in, job-layoff, spurned love interest or recent ego-boosting raise and promotion that has him a little dis-interested at this time. However if a woman cannot trigger a man's deeply sincere interest within a reasonable amount of time then she should move on. The most important thing, I feel, is for a woman to mirror, or reciprocate, the level of communication she receives from a man. He's said distance is an issue yet he's OK with writing. Yes, on the downside maybe he's just bored and looking for a pen-pal. But on the upside maybe he's just distracted or has been wounded previously and is moving forward fearfully. Sadly, the long answer is always more complicated but I'm an optimist.
# Posted By Mark Pennington | 8/9/09 2:49 PM
Steph's Gravatar He's just not that into you. (like the book says)
Anthony is right. If a man is into someone, he will pursue. Keep taking care of yourself, don't take this situation personally, and hold out for someone who is and will be into you.
# Posted By Steph | 8/9/09 3:06 PM
Patricia's Gravatar Hello! I agree with Mr. Buono's advice. Many times men are polite, but that does not mean they are interested in continuing emailing/writing/calling. My mom used to tell me "el interés tiene pies" meaning Interest has feet. I do not know if this is the r ight translation. I feel when a man really wants to pursue a woman he will do so.
Pray that the Lord will put those desires in your heart that are according to His will. Pray for your future husband, that God will lead you to him. God bless, Patricia.
# Posted By Patricia | 8/9/09 3:54 PM
Jeannine's Gravatar I agree with Anthony's advice on this. Save yourself the time and possible emotional attachment,unless you want to pursue a pen pal relationship with this man. I have found many AMS guys are seeking only pen pals, and this has been difficult to understand on a site like Ave Maria Singles.

It happens and it is up to the woman to continue to correspond or accept that someone is not open to a long distance relationship. It is better to know this as soon as possible. I hope this helps.

a fellow AMS member
# Posted By Jeannine | 8/9/09 4:15 PM
Patricia's Gravatar "However the long answer is that ... it depends upon the mood they're in."

Whatever does this mean? A guy has to be "in the mood" to seek out his vocation to marriage? I'm hoping you jest!
If he's not "in the mood" then maybe he should change his status to inactive.
Wow, I am stunned at this attempted justification to a lack of action on the part of the man.
# Posted By Patricia | 8/14/09 9:29 AM
Matt's Gravatar Helpful info on long-distance relationship From Mark Gaither, editor for Chuck Swindoll:

Men build monogamy upon a foundation of physical connection. By that, I don’t mean touching, necessarily. Physical connection involves much more. Men need to be physically present with a woman in order to bond with her emotionally, mentally, and spiritually. He wants to be near her, to share time and experiences with her, to see her face and hear her voice, even before touching her for the first time. Physical connection is both primal and primary, which explains why men commonly dismiss long-distance relationships as futile, like having no relationship at all. This is not to suggest that men are fundamentally shallow; they simply experience the deeper aspects of intimacy by means of their physical senses.

Women, on the other hand, build monogamy on a foundation of mental connection, which is no less primal or primary than a man’s need to experience his mate through the five senses. In the beginning, when a woman is drawn to a man she finds interesting, she wants to know all about him, his character, his ideas, his interests, his goals. Being in his presence merely serves this need, but letters and long discussions by phone will do just as well. Generally speaking, a woman can tolerate a long-distance romance much better than a man, as long as she continues to experience a rich mental connection with her lover.
It should come as no surprise then, that this mental connection remains foundational to a woman’s experience of intimacy. According to Harley, she needs affection, conversation, and honesty/openness more than anything. While men automatically assume that affection means touching, women think of affection in terms of its mental and emotional significance. A tender note or an unexpected call “just because” are no less meaningful than a hug or a peck on the cheek.
In addition to affection, a wife needs conversation and honesty/openness from her husband. This mental connection to her husband is crucial to her sense of well-being.
# Posted By Matt | 8/15/09 12:56 PM
Patricia's Gravatar Wow, great comment Matt! Thanks for sharing this.
# Posted By Patricia | 9/4/09 8:41 AM